top of page
G&G logo - NEW - RGB - shaded - REVERSED.png
AdobeStock_141023550.jpeg

WCB RELEASES 2012 GUIDELINES FOR DETERMINING PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT AND LOSS OF WAGE EARNING CAPACITY

  • Writer: GREY & GREY
    GREY & GREY
  • Jul 5, 2016
  • 2 min read

The Workers Compensation Board has finally issued the long-awaited 2012 Guidelines for Determining Permanent Impairment and Loss of Wage Earning Capacity (2012 Guidelines). The 2012 Guidelines continue the “schedule loss” criteria from the 1996 Guidelines. These criteria have served injured workers well for decades.

The Board’s medical impairment guidelines were adopted in their entirety from the September, 2010 report from the New York State Insurance Department. The Board has, however, added a “crosswalk” that permits severity ratings for different body parts to be compared on a 0-6 scale.

The 2012 Guidelines repeatedly state that medical impairment does not translate into loss of wage earning capacity, and that worker’s compensation benefits depend on the loss of wage earning capacity, rather than medical impairment. This is a significant shift from present workers compensation practice, which tends to minimize the consideration of functional loss and vocational factors except in rare instances (claims for total industrial disability).

The Insurance Department’s Task Force and Advisory Group specifically designed its medical impairment guidelines to prevent comparison of severity rankings across body parts in order to assist in shifting the system’s focus from medical impairment to loss of wage earning capacity. We are concerned that the Board’s creation of a “crosswalk” will undermine this goal. Instead of converting medical impairment into a series of letter rankings that cannot be translated into traditional “degrees of disability” as intended by the Task Force and Advisory Group, the “crosswalk” facilitates such translation. It is to be hoped that the Board will place a strong emphasis on the multiple portions of the 2012 Guidelines that prohibit conversion of medical impairment into compensation benefits and which require consideration of other factors.

Many portions of the 2012 Guidelines mandate evaluation of the impact of functional loss and vocational characteristics on loss of wage earning capacity. The Guidelines recognize that there are few employment options available for many workers who are limited to sedentary work as the result of occupational injury. Such workers have little if any earning capacity and must be protected by the workers compensation system.

There is a regrettable lack of guidance in the 2012 Guidelines regarding the respective weight of medical impairment, functional loss, and vocational factors, as well as the specific weight to be accorded to any given vocational factor. This approach permits an individualized assessment of each injured worker. However, the absence of guidance may well result in dissimilar outcomes in otherwise similar cases due to the variability inherent in the litigation process.

If the 2012 Guidelines are applied so that full and fair weight is given to the impact of functional loss and vocational factors on wage earning capacity, then the system may well achieve more substantial justice than it has in the past when inquiry was limited largely to medical impairment. If, however, the Board fails to properly emphasize the impact of functional loss and vocational factors, or if those factors are accorded insufficient weight in the ultimate determination, then substantial loss of benefits may occur due to the minimization of medical impairment under the new guidelines.

We will continue to monitor the implementation of the 2012 Guidelines and comment as appropriate.

Recent Posts

See All

BLOG POST

Grey & Grey, PLLC

Contact Us

Thanks for submitting!

Grey & Grey, PLLC is a law firm dedicated to the representation of workers who are injured on or off the job. We specialize in handling claims for Workers’ compensation, Social Security Disability, Disability Retirement, and Personal Injury.

Farmingdale Office

360 Main Street

Farmingdale, NY 11735

(516) 249-1342
Directions

Manhattan Office

111 Broadway Suite 809

New York, NY 10006

(212) 964-1342
Directions

Queens Office

118-35 Queens Boulevard Suite 1505

Forest Hills, NY 11375

(718) 268-5300
Directions

Suffolk Office

646 Main Street

Port Jefferson, NY 11777

(631) 249-1342
Directions

Westchester Office

203 East Post Road

White Plains, NY 10601

(914) 984-2292
Directions

Bronx Office

2932 Wilkinson Avenue, Room 503, Bronx, NY 10461

(718) 268-5300
Directions

Thanks for subscribing!

Terms & Conditions

Privacy Policy

Accessibility Statement

G&G logo - NEW - RGB - shaded.png

Disclaimer: Attorney Advertising.  The legal information presented on this site is not intended to offer any medical or legal advice. The content presented on this website is intended for educational purposes only. Visitors to this website should not substitute its content for the professional services of a legal or healthcare professional.  Reasonable attempts have been made to ensure the information presented on this website is accurate, and Grey & Grey cannot make express or implied representations or warranties about the completeness or accuracy of the contents of this website.  You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation.  Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship.  Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established. 

© 2025 by Grey & Grey, PLLC. All Rights Reserved. 

bottom of page